Google Places and Local SEO Before and After Ranking Comparison Reports – Coming Soon!
Spent the weekend cutting and pasting and doing graphic editing to make the custom ranking reports I need to show clients and I’m SICK OF IT! No one else does all this extra work and no one should have to! Grumble, grumble… Read on if you want new tools that can do all the manual labor I just did, automagically!!!
Here is a really bad example of a report I just wasted a ton of time cutting/pasting creating by hand. But hey, it helps me get paid for the next month of service!
Read on, below the image, for explanation and to learn how you can benefit from this post.
CLICK TO VIEW FULL SIZE
Sorry, really low res, copy of a copy. (Original didn’t look this bad but I blanked out City/client due a shady Dental SEO company that copies everything I do.)
NOTE: Reports above were generated by Places Scout which is my fav because it shows what type of ranking – 7 pack, blended, organic or Places. But I had to cut and paste 2 different reports, screw around with a graphics editor, re-size til it all fit, add the title and border etc. What a PAIN!!!
BACK STORY – I run ranking reports on my clients weekly for my OWN benefit, but I seldom show clients, because all the crazy Google dancing ups and downs are just confusing to them. But I do want to show before and after milestones. I’ll typically show a client a before and after of their results after I optimize their Place page and send it along with their 2nd month invoice so they can see the progress we’ve made. Then I’ll send another before and after, once I do their on-site SEO and their rankings make another jump. I send this with their 3rd month invoice, again so they can see how far we’ve come. The report above is one I just did this weekend.
HOW YOU CAN BENEFIT – I use both Bright Local and Places Scout. Each does different things I like and presents different data in different ways. Wish there was one program that did everything I need, the way I need it! Sigh…
I just emailed the head honcho at both companies on Sunday and showed them a copy of my jerry-rigged reports and explained how many steps it takes and how much time it takes to create these reports. Both companies got back with me IMMEDIATELY. How’s that for support? Both companies said they are working on a solution. However the “squeaky wheel“ gets the grease with coders and can move a new feature up the to-do list. So if you want this report comparison feature SQUEAK BELOW IN COMMENTS so I can show them how much you guys want this feature added!
BOTH COMPANIES are working on other MAJOR updates.
Places Scout is working on a HUGE new reputation management module. In addition to monitoring for negative reviews and bunch of other hot features, I just asked Mark to add 2 other features that are sorely needed in the industry. 1) Notification of ALL Places reviews so business owners will know about EVERY new review as it comes in. 2) Google Places review backup, so you’ll have a copy saved in case Google loses your reviews. I’ve had the report comparison feature on Mark’s to-do list, but his priority is getting the rep management update finished 1st. SQUEAK below to push comparison reports up the list.
Bright Local Rank Checker Myles got back with me right away on Sunday and it sounds like they already have something in the works that will satisfy this need. Myles replied “In February will be launching some new HTML reports which allow you to select start/end reports to compare against – you simple toggle the dates you need and the table updates. We will also be adding in some nice charts/analytics to make the data more visual and granular – you can see the performance of each individual keyword over time. We will make sharing ranking reports more easy by publishing them onto a generic URL which you can share direct with clients or pull in via iframe into your own site.”
So hooray! Awesome updates coming from both companies. Can’t wait to get the goods!
Am I too anal? Does anyone else see the need for this type of before and after ranking comparison report?
SQUEAK below if you’d like to help me push the developers to get this feature added to Places Scout and Bright Local, sooner rather than later.
Attention SEOs, Agencies & Google Places Consultants
Best Google Places Software & FREE Local SEO Tools&
Linda Now Offers ADVANCED Google Places Training
Including: templates, time savers, forms, cool optimization tricks & lots more
New here? Subscribe to RSS feed or follow me on Twitter. Thanks for visiting!



#1 Phil Rozek wrote on January 24, 2012 :
Hi Linda,
Well, if your rankings report is ugly, then mine’s FUGLY. Mine is basically the same, except it’s just an old-fashioned, unvarnished Excel spreadsheet. Same idea…just not exactly sexy.
You probably do this, but I also take before-and-after screenshots of every ranking–which can not only be nice proof to show my clients, but can also give me the raw materials to do some case-studies.
Thanks for the post in G+, btw!
#2 Linda Buquet wrote on January 24, 2012 :
Hey Phil, thanks for weighing in.
I didn’t hear your SQUEAK though!
Do you think the ability to select any 2 reports and do a comparison to show clients is a good idea? Would you like it to be more automatic, easier and nicer than doing it in Excel?
#3 Scott L Smith wrote on January 25, 2012 :
Hey Linda,
There are 2 “MUSTS” that I’ve found help both obtain and retain Clients:
1. You MUST be able to track your progress if you are going to keep Long-Term clients. Thus the need for Before and After “evidence” that your services are working. Clients will be able to tie this in with their increased sales (due to increase in visibility). Otherwise it’s your word against theirs that the work you’re doing is what actually boosted their revenue.
2. You MUST be able to provide visually attractive reports that CLIENTS can understand. This includes graphs and images in addition to the Cold numbers that us analysts love. Line Graphs, Bar Charts and Pie Charts are 3 quick visuals that Demonstrate our Hard Work in a way that Clients can relate to.
If you are unable to (A) “prove” the work you’ve done over a specific period of time and (B) present this “proof” in a way that the person cutting the check can understand, Guess What? – no more checky!
Scott L Smith recently posted..Blog Post with Pic
#4 Linda Buquet wrote on January 25, 2012 :
Hey Scott, totally agree!
Plus I get a personal rush from seeing a good before and after result. Week to week changes fluctuate and sometimes aren’t dramatic especially if you are gradually doing different campaigns to boost the ranking. But when you can compare 2 months ago before you optimized against today, for me it’s a big motivator and I’m excited to share the results with my client. Just don’t want to take all day to do the report.
#5 Phil Rozek wrote on January 25, 2012 :
Ah yes–a thousand pardons–my squeak…
One reason I don’t use rank-tracking tools much (at least now) is currently it’s just easier for me to do the before-and-after comparison myself. It doesn’t take me long at all to do this, but it is another to-do that takes a few minutes–minutes that I wouldn’t mind saving. But if there’s a rank-tracker that can give me a nice, (ideally) color-coded, before-and-after comparison more quickly than I can make one myself, then I’m all-in. The same is true of a lot of people I know.
Above all, the comparison needs to be simple, so that my clients don’t have to spend their valuable time trying to interpret it. I like the “Ugly Jerry-rigged” chart above…if a rank-tracker can pump THAT out more quickly than I can, I’d love it.
#6 Linda Buquet wrote on January 25, 2012 :
Thanks for the squeak and your very valuable 2 cents Phil!
#7 Vince wrote on January 26, 2012 :
Add me to the squeaky wheel list, Linda!
Come on guys at Places Scout and Bright Local, give us some nice, easy tracking and reporting features so we can show our customers their progress each month.
How do you think most of us Local SEO guys and gals continue to get paid?
By showing our clients RESULTS!
How do you think we can keep supporting and buying YOUR products?
If our clients keep PAYING US!
There ya go, not rocket science.
#8 Michelle Hartman wrote on January 29, 2012 :
Hi Linda,
As a fellow Carpal sufferer I too HATE having to do things manually AND repeatedly!!
I automate everything I can here but it would be brilliant if the guys at Places Scout and Bright Local could do some more of the work for us
Giving us more information in a way that we present to our clients directly is definitely the way forward, so please add me to your squeak list!
Michelle Hartman recently posted..Merry Christmas from Infonomix
#9 Linda Buquet wrote on January 29, 2012 :
Hey Michelle,
Sorry about your carpal. And considering that, an extra special thanks for taking the time to post and add your squeak!
#10 Myles wrote on January 29, 2012 :
Hi Linda
Thanks for including us in your post. We are very excited about the changes we’re making to BrightLocal – not just to our rank checker tool but to our overall service.
Here’s some extra info on these upcoming changes & dates – (you’ve heard it here first!)
6th Feb – launch new Google PLaces analysis tool – Google Places Wizard
6th Feb – launch bundled package with access to our 4 current tools (search rank checker, SEO check up, citationtracker, google places wizard)
15th Feb – analytics report launched for rank checker tool – easier comparison of results over longer time periods with nice charts/graphs.
1st March – rank checker reports will be made available on generic URLs which can be shared with clients. These reports/pages can be white-labeled with logo/colors.
I’m happy to answer any questions you guys have. You can reach me at myles@brightlocal.com
Thanks again Linda – keep up the great work
#11 Linda Buquet wrote on January 29, 2012 :
Awesome, awesome awesome Myles.
SO excited for all the new tools! You guys rock!
I’ll tweet this on Monday to help spread the word about all the updates!
#12 Linda Buquet wrote on January 30, 2012 :
Just finished working with Mark on his update. Wow so exciting. He’s just a wizard. SO FAST! Gave him lots of suggestions. He implemented everything right away and then gave me a demo of the new comparison report features. Got a preview of the reports in several formats and recommended a couple more changes. He just needs time to tweak, finalize and test.
But it rocks! Will be done soon and you guys will love it!
Linda Buquet recently posted..Google Places Review Problems? Google Places Support and Help
#13 Imprezzio wrote on February 1, 2012 :
I’ll “squeak” to both since our company uses both of them! I love Bright Local

Imprezzio recently posted..Online Ad Spending to Exceed Print for First Time Ever in 2012
#14 Linda Buquet wrote on February 1, 2012 :
Squeak, Squeak! Double squeak from Joy.
Sure glad I’m not the only one anal enough to keep going back and forth between 2 programs.
Another friend of mine is supposed to be coming out with something that will blow them all out of the water. Have not BETA tested yet, but will keep ya’ll posted.
#15 New Google Places Rank Tracking Comparison Reports Available – Places Scout - Google Places Optimization and Local SEO Blog wrote on February 14, 2012 :
[...] and Bright Local only showed improvement and changes since the previous report run. So I blogged end of January about how time consuming it was for me to cobble together reports that showed before and after [...]
#16 Linda Buquet wrote on February 14, 2012 :
Hey guys, the Places Scout ranking report comparison update just came out. Just blogged it with screen shots.
New Google Places Rank Tracking Comparison Reports Available – Places Scout
#17 Chris Gregory wrote on February 16, 2012 :
I’ll squeak and give two thumbs up on the URL to the report. I would add that the report be first customizable as other tools I use that do this show too much information for my clients. I want to select every detail that they see. I don’t want to explain the report each time I upload it. Some clients get it…others don’t.
Also, it would be great to show a history or timeline of the ranking results. The dates should be selectable by the user with the ability for a notes column. This will allow for notation of anomalies that take place such as a keyword moving from a 7 pack result to a blended result.
Chris
Chris Gregory recently posted..Goodbye Red Pins, Hello Yellow Reviews
#18 Linda Buquet wrote on February 16, 2012 :
Hi Chris, your squeak was already heard and answered.
See post above this one. Scout’s comparison feature is done and I think you’ll see it does most of what you want. (Also FYI right click to hide any columns you want)
#19 Chris Gregory wrote on February 16, 2012 :
Thanks Linda, I hadn’t had a chance to get to your other post yet. I’ll check it out.
Chris Gregory recently posted..Goodbye Red Pins, Hello Yellow Reviews